A freshman from Haverhill, Massachusetts, Nicolosi posted an 11-2 mark in the opening month of the season while competing at 165 pounds. Additionally, he boasted a 3-0 record in Conference Carolinas duals and a pair of runner-up finishes on the podium. In 11 victories, Nicolosi earned four falls, four decisions, two tech falls, and one forfeit, including a win over the nation's top-ranked wrestler at 165 pounds.