A freshman from Haverhill, Massachusetts, Nicolosi continued his stellar campaign after posting a 7-2 record in December with three decisions, two tech falls, and a pair of forfeits. He also entered NWCA individual rankings at No. 11 in the nation at 165 pounds. On Dec. 1, Nicolosi posted a perfect 3-0 record at the Carolina Clash with two victories over nationally ranked opponents. In the day's top performance, he defeated No. 1 ranked and defending national champion David Hunsberger of Lander by a 6-5 decision. In the next match, Nicolosi secured a second-ranked win over No. 6 Guy Deleonardis of Glenville State with a 2-1 decision.
At the Trojan Duals on Dec. 8, he captured two additional victories, including a 19-4 tech fall over Ya’Donnis Hardaway of Allen.
Nicolosi closed out the month with a solid performance at the Midwest Classic after advancing to day two of the tournament. He garnered a first-round bye before posting a 9-6 decision over Levi Deaguero of Adam State. Nicolosi advanced after defeating Kaden Renner of UMary by a 23-7 tech fall.