Herlihy scored four goals and assisted on the fifth goal in Ferrum's 5-2 non-conference win over Virginia State. She scored her first goal at the 34:30 mark and the two teams were tied 1-1 at the break. Her second goal came at 52:08, and her third was a penalty kick at 57:27. Her fourth goal was at 73:42, then she assisted on Jaden Hiers' goal at the 78:01 mark. She is only the second player in school history to notch four or more goals in a single game, and her nine points in a game are second all-time.